Sevilla Smith shoes are gorgeous, unusual, comfortable, and classic - and handmade with such care and good taste! Submitting this review during Thanksgiving week because I am grateful for beautifully-made everyday items that bring me delight and for Faye's exceptional customer service. Thank you!

I bought a pair in last year’s Black Friday sale and dubbed them my summer shoes - I had to wait 6 months to wear them, but by the end of the summer I had to get another pair! Truly every single time I wear my Sevilla Smith shoes, someone compliments me on them (both pairs) My flats did stretch a bit (my smaller foot is a little floppy now so I can’t do much more than a mile in them) but they are perfect to slide on for an errand walk. I’ve done a whole summer with them as an everyday shoe and the soles are barely worn.
My pair of loafers are what I’ve wanted for years. So many loafers have tons of seams and give me blisters or bother my ankles; these I’ve had no trouble with since I slipped them on! Again, compliments every time I wear them. So glad I invested in these statement shoes that will last me for years.

I have FIFTEEN pairs of Sevilla Smith shoes. I legit just counted them (12 in my closet, 3 in production). Suffice it to say: Sevilla Smith forever. The shoes are comfortable, timeless, unique, and so beautifully handmade. Every style I've tried, I have loved. What's extra amazing to me is how affordable the shoes remain even with customizations--beyond custom dyes, I've had a pair customized with holes so I could embroider on them.

Support small businesses, y'all! Buy handmade! You will not regret it!

I have several pairs of shoes from Faye and in my view they are just the absolute best in my collection! I love the 3 cm heels, bright colors, and on some pairs the ribbon laces. Superb!

I love THE PENNY! They can help dress up or dress down! Simple, comfortable and cool! Thank you!

So pleased to own such a beautifully crafted pair of shoes! I look forward to wearing them EVERYWHERE!

Lovely and unique shoes! My first pair has a bit of a fitting difference between left and right - the right one is tighter but the soft leather has already stretched a bit so I’m not worried they will be perfect soon! Otherwise very comfortable and I love the hand painted look!! My next pair is already ordered!

I purchased the Kim and they fit my feet like a glove, comfortable out of the box. I haven’t stopped wearing them and receive compliments every time I am out. I will definitely be getting more!

The shoes are very comfortable and required no break in. Needless to say, they are so stylish and unique that they will elevate whatever you are wearing. I am definitely coming back for a second pair!

Love the Kim shoes! I purchased the giraffe design after seeing them in pictures and falling in love. They are every bit as great as I had hoped. I initially ordered a size too large, and Faye helped troubleshoot via email, so I returned for a size down and removed part of the foam for a wonderful fit. The customer service process was excellent, and the shoes are amazing! So much so that I added tamarind edge-dyed + toast-tamarind bubbles to my collection during the recent sale. Tamarind is a beautiful deep brown, and the bubbles may just be the funnest thing in my wardrobe.

I have followed this company for awhile and never purchased until recently when I got the Kim in the sale. Now I’m kicking myself for not purchasing shoes sooner. They are extremely comfortable and very stylish, I can’t wait to go in a long adventure in them cause I know they will hold up and my feet will feel great all day long.

This is my first custom pair from Sevilla Smith. It's the Chuck in azure and the lake is nori hash. I Looovvee them!! I've received so many compliments. Like all Sevilla Smith shoes my Chucks are comfortable and are a show stopper. I am a size 38, in the Catu, and sized up for this pair.

I own a few pairs of Sevilla Smith shoes and all of them fit exceptionally great and are so comfortable. The Keiko also fits great! I had to go up a size, from my regular 38, due to the almond shape of the shoe. When they arrived, I pulled them out of the box and put them on right away. I wore them indoors and outdoors; walkings short and long distances; in the sun and in the rain. The claret colour is gorgeous, perfect for the fall season... actually any season! No need for the shoe to break in; no need to protect the leather: The Keiko fits like a glove!

Beautiful shoes and amazingly soft.

I’ve been so excited to try these shoes and took a chance on the sample sale. I’m loving my Keikos - the fit is perfect - I’m a pretty true 7/38 with a slightly wide toe box and the shoes have perfectly molded to my feet with zero pain or blisters from day one! I’ve walked miles in them in the first 10 days and have gotten so many compliments on the great color - Azure!
These will not be my only Sevilla Smith shoes and I can’t wait for the next pair!